Joined: 02 Mar 2009
Posts: 8934 votes: 3
Posted: Fri May 26, 2017 6:56 am Post subject:
Wynne defends 25% hydro rate cut: ‘All of those costs were on the shoulders of people today’
Premier Kathleen Wynne is making no apologies for the Liberals’ 25 per cent hydro rate cuts that a legislative watchdog warns will cost at least $21 billion over the next three decades.
“There were thousands of kilometres of line that needed to be rebuilt . . . that work hadn’t been done over those generations, so electricity costs were low over that period of time but the work wasn’t being done,” said Premier Kathleen Wynne.
By Robert BenzieQueen's Park Bureau Chief
Thu., May 25, 2017
Premier Kathleen Wynne is making no apologies for the Liberals’ 25 per cent hydro rate cuts that a legislative watchdog warns will cost at least $21 billion over three decades.
In the wake of Financial Accountability Officer Stephen LeClair’s report on the “Fair Hydro Plan,” Wynne emphasized that Ontario electricity consumers demanded and deserved relief.
“You all read the newspaper, you listen to the radio and you watch television — you know the problems that families are having around the province paying for their electricity costs,” the premier told reporters Thursday in Timmins.
That’s why the government moved forward with a rate cut that will see the average household’s monthly hydro bill drop from $156 to $123 once it fully takes effect next month.
In a 15-page report released Wednesday, the financial accountability officer estimated the initiative would cost the province $45 billion over the next 29 years while saving ratepayers $24 billion for a next expense of $21 billion.
Both the Progressive Conservatives and the New Democrats oppose the Liberal rate cut.
But Wynne said the government has in effect renegotiated a mortgage so it will bankroll hydro infrastructure improvements over a longer time period in order to give customers a break now.
“We’re talking about a 30-year window here. It took at least 30 years, probably 40 years, to let the electricity system degrade to the stage that it had in 2003,” she said, noting “we were having blackouts and brownouts around the province” before her party took office that year.
“There were thousands of kilometres of line that needed to be rebuilt . . . that work hadn’t been done over those generations, so electricity costs were low over that period of time but the work wasn’t being done.”
When her predecessor Dalton McGuinty came to power in 2003, Wynne said Queen’s Park began spending billions on infrastructure improvements, including expensive subsidies for green energy, such as wind turbines and solar panels.
“There’s a lot of work that has been done since then. Literally thousands of kilometres of line have been rebuilt. The coal-fired plants have been shut down. The air is cleaner. There’s less pollution in the air. The system is reliable and renewable,” she said.
“So there’s a cost associated with that and what was happening was that was work that had to be done — and all of those costs were on the shoulders of people today.”
Wynne noted “this electricity grid is an asset that is going to be used for generations to come.”
“My grandchildren are going to benefit from this asset, so I think it’s fair that we spread the cost of that over that 30-year period,” she said.
She has a point. But the big issue was that their CANDU reactors required serious retrofits after 15 years, rather than the 40 years the accountants had assumed. It meant that Hydro had been selling power for 15 years below cost without knowing it.
A lot of the rest of the problems is the result of running away, trying to hide their mistakes.
To me, it's an understandable mistake. You fire those immediately responsible and face facts about the situation. We didn't do that, probably because Hydro was a public company. Civil service attitudes seemed to apply. And that was the mistake.
Is Wynne really going to pin the whole mess on Harris? Do those wind-turbines have no role whatever in creating this bad taste that we in the public are experiencing? You know, that monthly kick-in-the-ass, the hydro bill?
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You cannot download files in this forum